Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Amy Brown's avatar

What a thoughtful piece, Jay, I really enjoyed it. You added such resonance and depth to the idea of "dignity," and there was much I didn't know about the German laws which protect it, for which I am glad (even if they are imperfect, they are still better than what we have in the US). This especially from your beautiful letter from love I appreciated: "Sweetie, I know how heavy the weight was you carried — the feeling of being overlooked, having to hide, being denied the freedom to simply be yourself. But I want you to know: Right here, right now, in this moment, you are whole." I see you, you ARE whole. Wishing the very best for you, Jay!

Expand full comment
Lily Pond's avatar

I read this essay with great interest. I appreciate your sharing of the agony of living "in the gap between the promises made and the reality experienced." It is absolutely not easy. As a second-class citizen, I can relate to that feeling, even though our struggles may be of a different nature.

It is amazing how Germany has enshrined "dignity" into its constitution, and I like your statement that dignity is our birth right. I agree with that 100%.

The problem with the American Constitution -- mainly, the way people interpret and apply it today, is that the "pursuit of happiness" is touted as the highest goal of life and an unquestioned quest of ALL people. Well, it may be true in one sense, but when everyone is out pursuing their happiness (open to interpretation), the part about sacrificing for the common good when such pursuits clash with one another is lost. Whereas, dignity is something that is unarguably a birth right and the desire of every single person who is born, regardless of their background.

Imagine a government established on this principle AND actually ensuring people of ALL backgrounds will live in dignity? We are definitely not there yet, but it doesn't mean we can't dream of one and work toward it. We can start with our own social circles.

Expand full comment
18 more comments...

No posts